Skip to content

 

←All Insights

You Can't Judge Your Firm From the Inside 

Most partners assume a lateral conversation means you've already decided to leave. It doesn't — and exploring is the only reliable way to know whether you should stay. A short video on what you can't see from where you sit.

3 Takeaways:

  • From the inside, every firm looks "normal." You can't evaluate your own platform without an outside look.

  • The firm that looks best on paper often isn't always the best fit — you learn that in the conversation, not before it.

  • Even if you decide to stay, you come back with information. And information is leverage.

Read the Transcript

Most partners hear "explore a lateral conversation" and assume it means one thing — that you've already decided to leave. So if you're not looking to leave, why take the meeting?

I'd flip that around. Exploring other firms isn't the decision to leave. It's the most reliable way to find out whether you should stay — and that's a question you genuinely can't answer from inside your own firm.

Let me walk through why, which is easy to miss when you're heads-down at a firm you've been at for years.

Start with the firm you're at right now. From the inside, it just looks like "normal." It's the water you swim in. Maybe you're underpaid. Maybe you're undervalued. Maybe you're on a platform where the resources always seem to flow somewhere else — another practice group, another office, everywhere but yours. Or maybe none of that's true, and you're in a genuinely good seat.

Here's the problem: from the inside, you can't actually tell which. You can't adequately evaluate your own firm's platform from within it.

An exploratory conversation with another firm is a mirror. Sometimes it shows you what you've quietly been tolerating for years. And sometimes it confirms you're exactly where you should be. Both are worth knowing. Neither is visible from the inside.

And once you start having exploratory conversations, something else tends to surface — something most partners don't expect.

The firm that looks best from ten thousand feet is rarely the one that fits best once you're in the room. I've lost count of the partners who ended up at a firm they'd have ranked second or third — or worse — going in, and it turned out to be exactly right.

Why does the aerial view get it so wrong? Because a name and a reputation don't tell you how the economics actually work, or how the firm would really support your practice, or whether the culture fits the way you practice law. You learn that from the conversation — not before it. Which is exactly why ruling out a firm before you've talked with them is so often a mistake.

But let's say you do all of this — you have the conversations, you evaluate — and you decide to stay right where you are. Even then, your time was well spent.

In fact, exploring might be the best thing you do for your position at your current firm. Here's what surprises partners: you go through a real lateral process, you receive an offer, and you decide to stay put. You didn't leave — but you didn't come back empty-handed either. You came back with information. And information is leverage. Now the conversation about your comp, your resources, your support isn't a wish or a hunch. It's grounded in what the market actually said you can command.

So the real question was never "Am I ready to leave?" It was "Do I actually know what I have?" And the honest answer is: not until you look.

When you do look, it often makes sense to look at more than one firm — but that's a conversation for another day. For now, it's enough to say this: exploring costs you a handful of conversations. Not exploring costs you years of assuming.

Jordan_Abshire_020

About

Jordan Abshire is the founder and managing member of Abshire Legal Search, established in 2012.  Jordan is the current V.P. of Strategic Planning for the National Association of Legal Search Consultants' Board of Directors.  Jordan has counseled countless partners with books of business ranging from 6 figures to 8 figures on getting a better deal at their current firm, assessing their value in the marketplace, and/or making a career-enhancing move.    

Before founding his firm, Jordan was a Principal at Lateral Link, managing the D.C. and Southeast markets. He previously practiced law with the energy group at Troutman Sanders LLP and clerked for Judge Henry Coke Morgan, Jr., in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. Jordan holds a J.D. from Harvard Law School and dual B.S. and B.A. degrees from Louisiana State University.

A Louisiana native now residing in Charlotte with his family, Jordan is dedicated to community service. He has volunteered at Roof Above, assisting men experiencing homelessness with resumes and job applications. He served on its board from 2017-2021 and launched and led Fortitude, a fitness initiative for Shelter Guests through F3. 

 
 

"Jordan Abshire is my Amex - I never leave my law firm without him!"

 
Partner
AmLaw 50 Firm

Want a read on your own situation? 

If you'd like a confidential, no-obligation conversation about where you actually stand, I'm glad to talk.

Watch the Companion Video: